Is God an Infanticide Perpetrator?

The short answer, yes!

Infanticide-the definition: the deliberate killing of an infant or very young child.

Perpetrator-the definition: someone who has committed a crime or a violent or harmful act. 

The evidence:

1 – The Death of Egypt’s Firstborn

God directly kills the firstborn in Egypt during the tenth plague.

“At midnight the Lord struck down all the firstborn in Egypt…”

— Exodus 12:29 

This would have included infants and children, not just adults.  

2 – Command to Kill Amalekite Infants

God (through Samuel) orders Saul:

“Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants…”

— 1 Samuel 15:3  

This is one of the most explicit verses where God is portrayed as ordering infanticide.  

3 – Midianite Boys Ordered Killed

After war with Midian:

“Now kill all the boys…”

— Numbers 31:17  

The command is presented as coming from Moses under God’s direction after divine anger against Midian.  

4 – David’s Infant Son

After David’s sin with Bathsheba:

“The Lord struck the child… and he died.”

— 2 Samuel 12:15–18  

This is a direct statement that God caused the death of David’s infant son.  

5 – Prophetic Judgment on Samaria

A prophecy of judgment attributed to God:

“Their little ones will be dashed to pieces…”

— Hosea 13:16  

The violence is carried out by invading armies, but it is described as divine judgment.  

6 – Prophecy Against Babylon

Again in judgment language:

“Their infants will be dashed in pieces before their eyes…”

— Isaiah 13:16  

Same pattern—human armies, but within a prophecy of God’s judgment. 

7 – Noah’s Flood

God destroys all life on earth except those on the ark.

“Every living thing on the face of the earth was wiped out…”

— Genesis 7:21–23  

The Irony 

Christianity clearly condemned infanticide, even though the New Testament itself does not contain a direct verse saying “do not commit infanticide.” The evidence comes from early Christian writings and later Christian-influenced Roman laws.  

The clearest early Christian statement is from the Didache—The Lord’s Teaching Through the Twelve Apostles to the Nations (late 1st or early 2nd century), which says:

“You shall not abort a child or commit infanticide.”  

Another early Christian text, the Epistle of Barnabas, gives a similar prohibition:

“Thou shalt not slay the child by procuring abortion; nor, again, shalt thou destroy it after it is born.”  

Summary

A so-called perfect, loving, passionate God character in the Bible killed (murdered) innocent infants for the following reasons:

  • Judgment on a society or nation – e.g., the Flood or destruction of cities, where infants are included in a broader judgment on humanity (Genesis 6–7).
  • Punishment for sin – e.g., David’s child in 2 Samuel 12, where the child’s death is presented as punishment connected to David’s actions.
  • Wrath / anger against enemies or wickedness – e.g., Egypt’s firstborn (Exodus 12) or Amalek (1 Samuel 15), where divine anger and judgment are the stated reasons.
  • Regret – in the Flood story, Genesis says God “regretted” making humanity, which leads into the destruction (Genesis 6:6–7).

The “perfect” God is not perfect. He had regret which is an admission he made a mistake. He killed children for the sins of their parents. 

How can anyone worship a baby killer and call that deity a loving, passionate God?

Questioning Christianity Homepage

Leave a comment